Institutionalization of Children – To Groom or To Ground?

Institutionalization of Children – To Groom or To Ground?

Author: Umadevi Achari
II Year | University of Mumbai Law Academy

Introduction:

Children need to be nurtured and fostered in a congenial atmosphere for their overall development. Special homes under the Juvenile Justice system are run to keep juveniles under one umbrella. They are placed in such homes with the aim of transforming and making them a contributing member of the society. However, juveniles get exposed to a confined outlook and space within such spaces. Therefore, institutionalization limits free-thinking. More often than not, it results in more harm than good.

In this article, the author begins by tracing some of the reasons behind deviant behaviour in children. The author then highlights the different kinds of special homes. Lastly, the author also discusses the problems faced by institutionalised children as well as the methods to combat these problems towards the conclusion.

Social Influences in Children’s Lives:

It’s essential to understand why a juvenile commits a crime in order to prevent future crimes from happening. Addressing these issues can help to prevent juvenile delinquency in the future.

  • Family Life

If a child has a rough family life, it’s more likely that they will fall into criminal activity[1]. When parents are not emotionally or physically available to guide their children, it makes them feel empty and lost, thus leading to trouble. Therefore, in an effort to fill this gap, many children turn to crime.

  • Violence in Surroundings

Violence at home or violence in the friend circle is another major factor in juvenile delinquency[2]. Children who are physically or emotionally hurt lash out in various ways. Violence of any sort can be harmful to a child who does not know why it is occurring or how to protect himself from it. Abuse is also one of the leading factors of juvenile crime[3].

  • Peer Pressure

Peer pressure from direct acquaintances can affect how a juvenile reacts to bad situations. Children want to ‘belong’ within their peer group. If their friends are committing law-breaking acts, the children may feel pressured to do the same to be accepted.

Types of special homes:

Juveniles stand a high chance of being wrongly influenced in special homes due to lack of personal care and attention.

  1. Resource Centres

It’s a place where psych-social support services and guidance are provided to children in conflict with law and other needy children.

These provide food, shelter, clothing and counselling to the children referred by the Juvenile Justice Boards (JJB) and Child Welfare Committees.

  • Special Homes

The children in conflict with the law are allowed to stay in the Special Homes for rehabilitation for a period of 3 years[5].  Many services are provided within these homes such as education, vocational training, counselling etc. The state governments are empowered to maintain and establish special homes in every district or every group of districts[6]. States may do so either by themselves or under an agreement with voluntary organizations.

  • Observation Homes

These homes are meant for the temporary reception of juveniles who are alleged to have come in conflict with the law[7]. Observation homes house the children whose enquiries are pending before the JJBs. Only children in conflict with law are produced before the Juvenile Justice Board constituted as per the section 4 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000[8]. The arrested children are normally detained under probation up to 4 months in these homes.

Problems faced by Institutionalized Children:

It’s important to understand that juveniles are forced to commit crimes for many reasons. These issues can affect children and have immediate as well as long-term consequences, consequently impairing their ability to function normally.

Children kept in these homes undergo separation anxiety, lack of bonding and loneliness leading to monotony and lack of creativity. They also experience emotional deprivation, anonymity and lack of personal attention,[9] which frustrates the motive of placing the children in these homes.

The behavioural problems amongst the institutionalised children include restlessness, difficulty in concentration and becoming more aggressive, among others. They face difficulty in adjusting in society and fail to form relations based on trust. They also depict poor study habits.

There are strict rules in various homes like denial of children to talk to their inmates, or the officials/superintendents. Lack of friendly behaviour shown by the caretakers causes the juvenile to become more unfriendly and rude[10].

Solutions to eradicate this problem?

The 3 C’s (functions) of care-givers are Connect, Care and Cope and the 4 A’s (qualities) are Acceptance, Approval, Attention and Appreciation.

They have to provide crucial psycho-social support for children during emergency situations to help them overcome tough experiences. These efforts can include culturally and age-appropriate activities, such as sports and games to develop life skills and coping mechanisms.

Many people involved in spirituality teach principles (the art of living, thinking and leading a worthwhile life) which are not similar to religious institutions and are universal to all. The author strongly believes that spiritual institutions will be of great help in imparting certain values in children, like how to recreate their belief system, and how to interact with living beings, etc. Implementing this would produce tremendous transformation amongst the juveniles and they might become a more successful human being.

Conclusion:

“The faces of young people are the faces of our past, present and future. No segment in the society can match the power, idealism, enthusiasm and courage of the young people.”

More often than not, institutionalization ends up causing more harm than good to a child. Children need space that nurtures and moulds them into a responsible and contributing citizen of the society and the nation.

In conclusion, we can safely state that merely placing juveniles under special care institutions or observation homes won’t suffice. We need to take newer actions in order to safeguard and groom the future generation.


[1] Factors that Contributes to Juvenile Delinquency, WAUKESHA CRIMINAL ATTORNEY, (12th October, 2020, 10:45 PM) URL: https://waukeshacriminalattorneys.com/factors-causing-juvenile-delinquency/

[2] Factors Contributing to Juvenile Delinquency, BAYSINGER LAW, (12th October, 2020, 10:40 AM) URL: https://baysingerlaw.com/2018/03/factors-contributing-juvenile-delinquency/

[3] Lindsay Kramer, What are the Causes of Juvenile Delinquency, LEGAL BEAGLE, (12th October, 2020, 10:50 PM) URL: https://legalbeagle.com/5103746-causes-juvenile-delinquency.html

[4] Juvenile Offenders Risk Factors, CRIMINAL JUSTICE, (12th October, 2020, 11:00 PM) URL: http://criminal-justice.iresearchnet.com/forensic-psychology/juvenile-offenders-risk-factors/

[5] Section 9 of Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000

[6] Sanju Gangaraddi, Section 9 – Special Homes – Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000, SHARE YOUR ESSAYS, (12th October, 2020, 1:05 PM) URL: https://www.shareyouressays.com/knowledge/section-9-special-homes-juvenile-justice-care-and-protection-of-children-act-2000/120117

[7] Apil Khanal, Observation Homes (Section 8 of the Juvenile Justice), SHARE YOUR ESSAYS, (12th October, 2020, 1:10 PM) URL: https://www.shareyouressays.com/knowledge/observation-homes-section-8-of-the-juvenile-justice/119445

[8] Section 8 of Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000

[9] Divya Srivastava, Understaffed and Overcrowded Juveniles Homes are Hell Holes rather than Reform Centres, FIRST POST, (13th October, 2020, 9:30 AM) URL: https://www.firstpost.com/living/understaffed-and-overcrowded-juvenile-homes-are-hell-holes-rather-than-reform-centres-2842894.html

[10] Ashwaq Masoodi, Inside a Juvenile Home, LIVE MINT, (13th October, 2020, 9:30 AM) URL: https://www.livemint.com/Leisure/X4DChvj7KCXVjegtttegBI/Inside-a-juvenile-home.html

Editor: Pari Agrawal
Content Manager | Leagle Samiksha

14

14 Comments

KISHORE R SHINTRE

This artice has brought about an important aspect to child’s spiritual development, it is very essential that all the juvenile children are exposed to spirituality in their early age, they should be taught meditation, yoga and surya namaskar which would help them to develop their mind and body with positive energy and lead them to become good responsible citizens of the country.

Sangeeta Acharya

Children are the future resources of the country. They must be transformed from negative to positive personality. However, looking to the past experience, we have to bridge the wide gap between theory and practice. In this process, we have to build a good infrastructure and efficient Juvenile Justice Administration. The new legislation carry the dreams, we need to make the dream reality. The idea is gradually gaining wider acceptance that juvenile delinquent needs the sympathy and understanding of our society and not the heavy hand of the law.

Extremely well written and relevant given the meagre and inadequate resources available for children who are on the wrong side of the law.
How our systems improve and these children are provided with the necessary support to bloom in a nurturing environment.

Deepak Kumar

A good 🦅 (Eagle) view on one of the most discarded section & future of of society left in disdain.

Manisha Gude

Very nice article , relevant in today’s times . We need to channelize this kids and educate them in the right direction. Most of them must be coming from a disturbed family background where they must have seen domestic violence. Also they should be mainly taught anger control with meditation.

Umadevi Kamalnath Achari

Thanks a lot sir for sharing your wonderful thoughts

B Sreenivasan

Great ,very great, astonishing, unbelievable, it is super natural thinking power’ that all don’t get it at this tender age what that you have. I am wondering how such brilliant thoughts can go in to your mind what that I could not think in my 70s. Keep it up Uma ,sky is open for you, fly anywhere you want, you are a blessed child, we will shoulder you with our sweet hearts. Goodluck

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *